← The land

Story · 1749–1811 · v2.9

The Oosthuizens of Swellendam, 1749-1811

Before Modder Fonteyn it is Swellendam. All thirteen children of the 1749 marriage belong to that district, which then ran east over the mountains and took in the Little Karoo

Thirteen children were born to Jacobus Oosthuysen d'oude and Dina Carolina Brits after their marriage at Tulbagh in 1749, and every one of them belonged to the district of Swellendam - a district that then ran east over the mountains and took in the Little Karoo. Their estates show what these people actually owned: not land, but the opstal on a loan place, valued at ten rixdollars in one case and a thousand in another, with the rent to the Company years in arrears. The generation closes in six years, between 1799 and 1809, and it is their children who cross the Swartberg.

On 27 April 1802 a clerk sat down at the place of Pieter Cornelis Oosthuysen and wrote out what his parents still owned. A large chest and a wagon box. Two chairs and an old table. A tea kettle, twelve assorted plates, seven pewter spoons, a pepper box. Two axes, a plane, a pick, a spade and an iron for digging wild onions. A gun, and a cane with a silver mounting.

Jacobus Oosthuysen d'oude was dead and his widow, Dina Carolina Brits, had moved in with a son. So MOOC8/24.27 is not the inventory of a working household. It is what an old couple still had after they gave up their own roof.

No farm appears in it. The estate came to Rd 1382:5, and Rd 1082:5 of that was money owed by their own children. More than three quarters of what these two had left was out on loan inside the family, and the ground had gone to the next generation already.

Jacobus and Dina Carolina, and their thirteen children

Jacobus Oosthuysen and Dina Carolina Brits married at Tulbagh on 10 April 1749. Thirteen children followed over twenty-six years, and the family this site is built on descends from the third of them, Ockert, who is the father of the household that later crossed the Swartberg.

Child of Jacobus and Dina CarolinaBornDied
Catharina1751
Johannes Jacobus175326 June 1828
Ockert1755April 1809
Jacobus Nicolaas12 November 17551769
Jacobus Petrus1757before 1802
Gerrit Johannes10 February 17601825
Dina Johanna17621771
Marthinus17641799
Pieter Cornelis176725 December 1836
Jacobus8 October 1769before 1802
Dina Johanna Magdalena17711815
Adriaan25 December 1774by 16 August 1804
Jacoba Cornelia1777by 28 December 1805

Two of the thirteen are absent from the 1802 heirs list, and an heirs list carries a dead child's own children in that child's place. Jacobus Petrus and the second Jacobus had therefore both died before April 1802 with nobody surviving them. not yet verified

Their son Marthinus, the eighth child, had died in 1799, and his eight children are entered in his place. The clerk records where each of them was living: two with their uncle Pieter Cornelis, two with Johannes Mattheus Calitz, the rest elsewhere. Nobody went to an institution. There was none within reach, and there did not need to be.

One district, and it is not the district on the map today

Every one of these thirteen belonged to Swellendam.

Ockert married Susanna Catharina van Tonder there on 26 January 1783. The death notice of his eldest son, Jacobus Johannes, written sixty-four years later, still gives that son's birthplace as the Division of Swellendam. [SRC-451] His second son, Ockert Almero, married Adriana Cecilia Venter at Swellendam in October 1807. And the estates of Jacobus the father and Ockert the son were both handled from the same drostdy.

The 1802 inventory ends Mij present: A: Stockenstrom, Secret:s. The 1809 one ends Ten mynen overstaan: A:A: Faure. Anthony Alexander Faure was landdrost of Swellendam from 1798 to 1810, and in March 1796 General Craig had appointed Anders Stockenström as his secretary. [SRC-465] So Jacobus's estate went through the secretary and Ockert's through the landdrost: the same office, the same two men, seven years apart.

What that district contained is the part a modern map hides. Swellendam then ran east over the mountains and took in the Little Karoo and the Langkloof, and it was still growing. On 23 April 1811 the government cut George out of it because the magistracy had become too large, and the new district took in what are now Mossel Bay, Calitzdorp, Oudtshoorn, Uniondale and Knysna. A family that never moved could be Swellendam people one year and George people the next.

What a man actually owned

Almost none of this ground was owned. It was held on loan from the Company at an annual recognitie, and what a man could sell or leave to his children was the opstal: the house, the kraals, the werf, the improvements. The land underneath stayed the government's.

The values in the Orphan Chamber's books make the point better than any description. [SRC-467] When Willem Marthinus Oosthuizen died in 1776 his opstal on the loan place de Modder Fenteijn, on the Kafferkuils River, was taxed at Rd 10. In 1792 the opstal on Welbedagt in the Attaquaskloof came to Rd 133:16. In 1809 the whole place at de Modder Fonteyn on the Olifants was sold to Ockert's eldest son Jacobus Johannes for Rd 1000, of which Rd 344 had been paid off by the following December.

A rented house, in other words, and the rent ran behind. The Welbedagt estate owed the Company ten years and six months of arrears on its place. That is not carelessness. It is what holding ground on credit looked like when the nearest drostdy was a week away.

One of the family's loan places can now be found on a modern map, and it carries a family name. The 1805 roll's farm column puts Ockerts Kraal against the household of Gerrit Johannes Oosthuizen — Ockert's own brother — read across the gutter on the wife's name, Susanna la Gransie [SRC-497]. In August 2026 the farm's diagram surfaced: Ockerts Kraal is No. 502 in the Swellendam division, 3,706 morgen on the Touw and Doorn Rivers below the Warm Water Berg, in the field cornetcy of Groote Swarteberg [SRC-574]. By the time it was surveyed in 1838 the grant went to a Forie, not an Oosthuizen — the family had left or lost the place — and whether the name itself is older than the family's tenure, and whose kraal it first was, is an open question of this record.

The Olifants River

1680170017201740176017801800held, lived on or recorded at: 1809/ loan farmheld, lived on or recorded at: 1782~ loan farm; 1780 loan farmheld, lived on or recorded at: 1772 loan farmheld, lived on or recorded at: ../1805 loan farm; ../1808-09-23 loan farmheld, lived on or recorded at: 1765 loan farmheld, lived on or recorded at: 1765 loan farmmarried: 1807-10parent and childparent and childmarried: 1783-01-26parent and childparent and childparent and childparent and childparent and childparent and childmarried: 1749-04-10parent and childparent and childparent and childparent and childparent and childparent and childparent and childparent and childparent and childparent and childparent and childparent and childparent and childparent and childparent and childparent and childparent and childparent and childparent and childparent and childparent and childparent and childparent and childparent and childparent and childparent and childmarried: 1702~parent and childparent and childparent and childparent and childmarried: 1735-10-23married: 1773-05-30parent and childparent and childOckert Almero Oosthuizen (1786–1859)Ockert Almero Oosthuizen1786–1859Adriana Cecilia Venter (1792–1858)Adriana Cecilia Venter1792–1858Ockert Jacobus Oosthuizen (1755–1809)Ockert Jacobus Oosthuizen1755–1809Susanna Catharina van Tonder (1763–)Susanna Catharina van Tonder1763–Pieter Marthinus Oosthuijzen (1795–)Pieter Marthinus Oosthuijzen1795–Jacobus Johannes Oosthuizen (1784–1867)Jacobus Johannes Oosthuizen1784–1867Jacobus Oosthuizen (1722–1802)Jacobus Oosthuizen1722–1802Dina Carolina Britz (1732–1802)Dina Carolina Britz1732–1802Catharina Oosthuizen (1751–)Catharina Oosthuizen1751–Johannes Jacobus Oosthuizen (1753–1828)Johannes Jacobus Oosthuizen1753–1828Jacobus Petrus Oosthuizen (1757–)Jacobus Petrus Oosthuizen1757–Gerrit Johannes Oosthuizen (1760–1825)Gerrit Johannes Oosthuizen1760–1825Dina Johanna Oosthuizen (1762–1771)Dina Johanna Oosthuizen1762–1771Marthinus Oosthuizen (1764–1799)Marthinus Oosthuizen1764–1799Pieter Cornelis Oosthuizen (1767–1836)Pieter Cornelis Oosthuizen1767–1836Jacobus Oosthuizen (1769–)Jacobus Oosthuizen1769–Dina Johanna Magdalena Oosthuizen (1771–1815)Dina Johanna Magdalena Oosthuizen1771–1815Adriaan Oosthuizen (1774–1804)Adriaan Oosthuizen1774–1804Jacoba Cornelia Oosthuizen (1777–1805)Jacoba Cornelia Oosthuizen1777–1805Johannes "Jan" Oosthuijsz (1665–1730)Johannes "Jan" Oosthuijsz1665–1730Johanna Martens (1679–1734)Johanna Martens1679–1734Jacobus Nicolaas Oosthuizen (1755–1769)Jacobus Nicolaas Oosthuizen1755–1769Johannes Mattheus Calitz (1748–)Johannes Mattheus Calitz1748–Jan Hendrik Oosthuijsen (1714–1780)Jan Hendrik Oosthuijsen1714–1780Marthinus Oosthuizen (1743–1792)Marthinus Oosthuizen1743–1792Willem Marthinus Oosthuizen (1739–1776)Willem Marthinus Oosthuizen1739–1776Ockert Olivier d'oudeOckert Olivier d'oudeHester Cicilia Olivier (1756–1808)Hester Cicilia Olivier1756–1808Anna Botha (1718–1780)Anna Botha1718–1780De Modder FonteynDe Modder FonteynWelbedagt No. 150Welbedagt No. 150Ockerts Kraal No. 200Ockerts Kraal No. 200Gamthous BerghGamthous BerghArmoed No. 159Armoed No. 159

parent and childmarriedheld, lived on or recorded atHover over or tap a name to see who and what it is joined to.

The direct line had its own ground on this river. In 1765 Jacobus took the loan place Gamthous Bergh, on the Canna, the water its own survey of 1818 calls the Kandelaarsrivier. [SRC-667] [SRC-668] Ockert Olivier's Armoed lay between it and Welbedagt, nine kilometres the one way and ten the other, and in 1773 the two families married.

The Orphan Chamber's clerks wrote d'Olifants rivier seventy times in the volumes that have been transcribed, and in this district they usually meant the southern one: the river that rises on the Traka north of the Swartberg and runs west past Oudtshoorn to the Gouritz. They write it agter de Cango, inde Attaquascloof, aan de Kaukoe, districkt George. Fifteen of the mentions place themselves that way and one places itself at the Piquet Berg. [SRC-467]

A tax roll settles the geography that the phrases only suggest. The George roll of 1813 heads its wards in the order the field cornet rode them, and the order runs Boven Oliphants Rivier, then de Cango, then Attaquas Kloof. [SRC-564] Those are the same three names the Orphan Chamber's clerks reach for, standing in a line along one river. The upper Olifants, the Cango behind it, the kloof at the end: a ward sequence, not a scatter of guesses.

Oosthuysens were living on that river before this generation had finished raising its children. In 1792 the widow of Marthinus Oosthuysen Jansz was left with five children and the loan place Welbedagt in the Attaquaskloof. The loan-farm register puts him on it from 1780, after Ockert Olivier, who had held it since 1772; the arrears run from about 1782. He had married Hester Cicilia Olivier in 1773, so the place came to him the way ground usually moved, with a marriage. The inventory was made on the ground and signed there: Aan de Oliphants Rivier op voorn: plaatz den 18 Maij 1792. One of the three men who appraised it was an Oosthuysen, and another was Ockert Olivier himself.

That Marthinus was Jan's son and this family are Jacobus's, and the two fathers turn out to be brothers. Jan Hendrik Oosthuijsen, 1714 to 1780, married Anna Botha at Stellenbosch on 23 October 1735 and had ten children; his own parents are Johannes Oosthuijsz and Johanna Martens, who married at Drakenstein about 1702 and whose nine children include Jacobus of 1722. [FS]

So Marthinus of Welbedagt is a first cousin of Ockert, and Willem Marthinus of the Kafferkuils Modder Fenteijn is his brother. Two cousins of this household, holding two loan places sixty kilometres apart, one on the Olifants and one on the water that runs to the sea.

The farm name was ordinary too. Modderfontein turns up ten times over in these volumes, on the Kafferkuils, behind the Piketberg, behind Bruintjieshoogte, on two different Riet rivers and once in Namaqualand. The name identified nobody, which is exactly why a clerk always added the water.

Four deaths, and the ground goes

Marthinus, the eighth child, died in 1799 and left eight children to be parcelled out. Jacobus the father died in 1802. Adriaan died next, and his estate was taxed at the Weeskamer on 16 August 1804: a widow, Catharina Petronella Horn, and five children aged eight, six, five, two and ten months. The whole of it came to Rd 448. A bed, three chests, two chairs, a plough, an ox-wagon, eleven trek oxen, four head of cattle, a mare, 124 goats and 43 sheep. No opstal, no loan place, no ground of any kind.

The following year the Chamber inventoried the estate of a Jacoba Cornelia Oosthuizen, on 28 December 1805, and it was her brother Pieter Cornelis who took it. She had married twice, to Jan Emmenes and then to Jacob van den Bank, and one of her daughters carries her mother's name, Dina Carolina. She is the sister born in 1777: the estate names her brother as the man who appraised it, and the model carries her death from this sheet rather than from the 1870 the compiled trees once gave her.

Then Ockert, in April 1809, at de Modder Fonteyn on the Olifants, leaving eleven children of whom seven were still minors.

Where it goes from here

Three of Ockert's eleven crossed the Swartberg: Jacobus Johannes, Ockert Almero and Pieter Marthinus. By 1816 the whole connection was enrolled in the George district, in one field cornetcy, four Oosthuizen households deep with four Strydom households beside them, and two further rows that one reading makes Oosthuizen and another makes Olivier. [SRC-459] [SRC-468] By 1833 three brothers held three adjoining farms on the north side of the mountain, and that is where this site begins.

The generation in this piece never made that move. They married at Swellendam, farmed on loan places between the Kafferkuils and the Olifants, buried each other within six years, and left their children a wagon, a plough and a debt to the Company. What Jacobus Johannes bought at de Modder Fonteyn for a thousand rixdollars was not a farm. It was a house on somebody else's ground, and a promise to raise his brothers and sisters.

Where to read on

the road itself, in four movesHow the Oosthuizens came to the Koup
the day the household broke upFrom Modder Fonteyn to the Koup
what they did once they were hereThe Oosthuizens of the Koup

What this story is about

Sources

Everything this story rests on, with a link to the original wherever one exists. Where a citation is incomplete it says so, an incomplete citation is a research gap, not a formatting problem. If your work is here and the credit is wrong or thin, please tell us and it will be fixed.

  1. MOOC8/24.27 - Inventory of the estate of Jacobus Oosthuysen d'oude and his widow Dina Carolina Brits, taken 27 April 1802 Cape Archives (KAB), Master of the Orphan Chamber; transcription published by TANAP / Globalise (Huygens KNAW)MOOC8/24.27, {18020427} | *** THE PAGES THEMSELVES SEEN 20 Aug 2026, supplied by [FAMILY] Three openings, the item number 27 written in the margin of the first, and 'Faded Document' on the archive's own slip. ***.view it online →
  2. MOOC8/28.63 - Inventory of the estate of Ockert Oosthuijzen, taken at de Modder Fonteyn on the Olifants River, 23 April 1809 Cape Archives (KAB), Master of the Orphan Chamber; transcription published by TANAP / Globalise (Huygens KNAW)MOOC8/28.63, {18090423}view it online →
  3. Death Notice 3999½ - Jacobus Johannes Oosthuizen, died 29 October 1867 at Grootfontein, division Colesberg FamilySearch, "Cape, Probate Records of the Master of the High Court, 1822-1990" [TO VERIFY - the collection is inferred from the form and the hand, matching SRC-077; no breadcrumb, waypoint, film or DGS number has been seen]Death Notice no. 3999½, filed 19 December 1867; two images, seen as image 1213 of 2192 [TO VERIFY] Citation incomplete: Supplied as a screenshot. The ark and film/image numbers were never captured, so the original cannot be ordered from this entry alone.
  4. George district opgaafrol, 1816 (volume J 97) - four Oosthuizen brothers, a sister and their Strydom, Venter and Schoeman spouses on one opening, and a farm entered as Modder fontyn FamilySearch film 008145125, images 43, 45 and 46 of 746. THE FILM'S OWN TARGET CARD, photographed by , reads: microfilmed by the Genealogical Society of Salt Lake City at GOV ARCHIVES CAPE TOWN RSA; LOCALITY OF RECORD "GEORGE, CAPE PROVINCE"; TITLE OF RECORD "OPGAAFROLLEN"; "CENSUS - TAX"; VOLUME/S "J 97"; YEAR/S INCLUDED "1816"; operator C. Marais, filmed 10 May 1978, emulsion 5460-394-361, project S-AF 20 B, roll 13.Film 008145125, image 45 of 746 (households); image 46 (landeryen and mortaliteit columns); image 43 (preceding page)
  5. Who A.A. Faure was, and what the district of Swellendam contained in April 1809 Secondary and tertiary web sources, consulted 17 Aug 2026 - Geni and WikiTree for Faure; the town of George's published histories and Wikipedia for the 1811 divisionFaure's TENURE DATES (1798-1810) and the 1811 George proclamation are still [TO VERIFY] against an archival source - the Cape almanacs or KAB 1/SWM, and the proclamation itself. That he held the office of landdrost te Zwellendam IN 1809 is no longer web-sourced: it is stated in MOOC8/28.22, 26.65 and 25.18. SRC-549.view it online →
  6. A sweep of the whole published MOOC8 for Modderfontein, for the Olifants river, and for every farm named in an Oosthuizen estate TANAP / Globalise (Huygens KNAW), Cape transcriptions, Orphan Chamber MOOC8Volumes searched: MOOC8_1-5, 6-10, 11-15, 16-20, 21-30, 31-40, 41-45, 46-50, 51-60, 71-75 - every group the collection index publishes. MOOC8/61-70 and 76+ ARE NOT TRANSCRIBED, so the sweep is complete for what exists online and not for the series.view it online →
  7. A second transcription of film 008145125 images 45-46, supplied as a spreadsheet Supplied 18 Aug 2026 as Opgaafrol_GraaffReinet_img45-46_transcription.xlsx. Three sheets: Transcription (23 households), Column structure, Source & caveats.Film 008145125 images 45 and 46; the sheet gives the ark for image 46 as 3:1:3Q9M-CSK8-LPT7
  8. The ward sequence of the 1813 George roll - Boven Oliphants Rivier, de CANGO, then Attaquas Kloof - and the rule that reads it FamilySearch, film # 008145124; George district opgaafrollen, volume J 90, year 1813Film # 008145124, IMAGES 123, 124, the page following 124, 132, 181, 185, 187 and 192 of 545 - the title leaf, the roll's first household page, and the heads of successive openings showing their 'P:r Transport' lines.

Research notes

Written, to the STORY-VOICE standard. Built on the two Orphan Chamber estates this project already held (SRC-093, SRC-092) and on the MOOC8 sweep of 17-18 Aug (SRC-467), with the Swellendam jurisdiction from SRC-465.

TWO CONFLICTS ARE STATED IN THE STORY RATHER THAN RESOLVED: Jacoba Cornelia's death is 28 Dec 1805 in the compiled trees and in an Orphan Chamber inventory taken by her brother, and 1870 on PER-000246; and Adriaan's estate was taxed at the Weeskamer on 16 Aug 1804 while PER-000245 carries 1805. Both flagged for Frans, neither changed inside a story pass.

Willem Marten Oosthuijsen, who held a Modder Fenteijn on the Kafferkuils in 1776, is named and deliberately NOT linked: he is not in this model and no kinship is claimed.

v1.1 [18 Aug 2026]: THREE FACT CHANGES, two of them corrections. (1) The FamilySearch family view confirms what a compiled tree had only suggested: JAN HENDRIK OOSTHUIJSEN (1714-1780) and JACOBUS (1722) are brothers, sons of Johannes Oosthuijsz and Johanna MartensM who married at Drakenstein about 1702. So Marthinus of Welbedagt is a FIRST COUSIN of Ockert, and the sentence saying the connection "is not known" is gone. (2) WILLEM MARTHINUS OOSTHUIZEN (1739-1776), who held the Modder Fenteijn on the Kafferkuils, is Jan Hendrik's son too and so Marthinus's BROTHER - PER-001855, added the same day. The panel item saying he had not been placed is gone. (3) THE HOUSEHOLD COUNT IS CORRECTED FROM SIX TO FOUR: a second transcription of the 1816 opening (SRC-468) reads as OLIVIER two of the rows read here as Oosthuizen, and neither reading comes from the manuscript. The page now says four, names the disagreement, and the panel carries it.

v2.0 [18 Aug 2026] RE-VOICED, both languages, after HE WAS RIGHT AND THE FAULT RAN THROUGH THE WHOLE PIECE. The heading 'The thirteen' named nobody; 'The couple married at Tulbagh' asked the reader to carry a couple across a section break; 'descends from the third' never said Ockert; 'his eldest son' and 'the eldest son' were Jacobus Johannes four times without being named; 'Marthinus died in 1799' was ambiguous between three Marthinuses in the same story; 'the father', 'these people', 'those eleven' all stood for people the reader had to reconstruct. Every one is now named, and the table's first column is labelled.

AND EVERY NAMED PERSON WHO HAS A ROW IS NOW A LINK - 26 person links, up from 20: Susanna Catharina van TonderM, Adriana Cecilia VenterM, Johannes Mattheus CalitzL, and the narrative mentions of Marthinus of Welbedagt, Jacoba Cornelia and Pieter Cornelis where they are discussed rather than only where they appear in a table.

WHY THE VOICE PASS MISSED IT: STORY-VOICE's rule 'place a person before you ask the reader to remember them' is one checks.py cannot see. The file scored 0 narration, 0 bold-sentence, 0 punchline-ending, and that was taken as finished - which is the exact thing the standard warns against where it says a zero does not mean the voice is right.

[25 Aug 2026, currency review] v2.1: Ockerts Kraal found on the map: No. 502 Swellendam, the brother's 1805 holding, the 1838 Forie grant.

[27 Aug 2026] AFRIKAANS LANGUAGE PASS, v2.2: rhythm, tone particles and the gedagtestreep. NOT a content change; verify_af confirms every fact of the English twin survives and the English is untouched. *** ONE REAL DEFECT FIXED IN PASSING: the Afrikaans carried a duplicated fragment mid-sentence, 'Die vader se boedel het deur die sekretaris' standing in front of the correct clause, so the passage about Stockenstrom and Faure did not parse. The English twin has the sentence intact, which is what it was restored from.

[27 Aug 2026] RESEARCH SWEEP, v2.3: the George roll of 1813 heads its wards in the order the field cornet rode them - Boven Oliphans Rivier, then de Cango, then Attaquas Kloof (SRC-564). Those are the same three names the Orphan Chamber's clerks reach for when they place a household, standing in a line along one river. It turns a scatter of phrases into a ward sequence and it had been in the model since 23 August.

v+ 28 Aug 2026: title and subtitle set. Frans's draft subtitle read 'in die soeke na die Oosthuizens se Modder Fonteyn tref ONS hulle in Swellendam aan', which narrates the search rather than the history - the shape 10 removed from seventy places across 23 story files. The orienting intent is kept and the researchers are out of it: 'Voor Modder Fonteyn is dit Swellendam.'

v+ 28 Aug 2026: Cross-link added to S044.

[22 Sep 2026] v2.6: Welbedagt's holders corrected from the loan-farm registers (SRC-669) - Ockert Olivier from 1772, Marthinus from 1780 after his 1773 marriage to Hester Cicilia OlivierM, the arrears from about 1782. And the appraisers: the sheet names ONE Oosthuysen among the three, with Ockert Olivier as another; the page had said two of three.

[22 Sep 2026] v2.7: a people-and-places diagram on the Olifants River section, and the paragraph it needed - Jacobus's own loan place Gamthous Bergh on the Canna in 1765, Ockert Olivier's Armoed between it and Welbedagt, and the marriage of 1773. The diagram draws 33 people and 5 farms, including Anna BothaM, Hester Cicilia OlivierM and Ockert Olivier, none of whom the site could show before.

[22 Sep 2026] v2.8: the Afrikaans of last night's new paragraph rewritten as Afrikaans rather than carried over from the English - the ambiguous 'sy eie opmeting' became 'die plaas se eie opmeting', one long sentence became four, and the emphasis moved onto 'dit' with the accent. Also 'die boedels van Jacobus die vader en Ockert die seun' to 'Jacobus die vader en Ockert die seun se boedels', which is the se-possessive the language uses.

[23 Sep 2026, reconciliation] v2.9: the children's table caught up with the model after another session's MOOC8 corrections - Johannes Jacobus died 26 June 1828 not the 20th, Adriaan by 16 August 1804, Jacoba Cornelia by 28 December 1805. And the sentence saying this site's own record gives her 1870 is gone: it does not any more, and the estate names her brother as the appraiser.

The research behind this page, kept separate from it: dated working notes, open questions, and what is not yet settled.